Few things polish off a makeup look quite like mascara. But with so many different options on the market, finding your perfect match can feel overwhelming. Whether you prefer tubing mascara over the regular version has become a way to narrow your search, besides color or finish. While both provide lash-lengthening benefits, a tubing mascara offers a few unique advantages you may not be familiar with. Here, we’ll explain what tubing mascara is, as well as what it does, and share the benefits of using this type of mascara. We’re also giving you the inside scoop on the best drugstore tubing mascara from L’Oréal Paris and how to apply it. All the details await you ahead.
Shop the Product
What Is Tubing Mascara?
Tubing mascara is a type of mascara that forms extension-like “tubes” around your eyelashes for a smudge-proof, lash-lengthening effect. The main difference between tubing mascara vs. regular mascara lies in the formula. The former contains polymers that create a lash-elongating cocoon around your eyelashes, while the latter coats your lashes in buildable layers of pigment.
Tubing mascaras are a popular option because they provide natural-looking lift and length and, once dry, won’t smudge—even if you have oily lids. Plus, tubing mascara can target each eyelash, making it an excellent option for separating and defining your lashes and helping them hold a curl.
How does tubing mascara work?
As mentioned, tubing mascaras contain unique polymers that form a flexible, tube-like structure around each individual lash. These tubes help elongate and define your lashes for a natural-looking lash look—no clumping, flaking, or smudging. Most formulas rinse off easily with a bit of warm water, though some brands do make waterproof tubing mascaras, as well.
Perks of using tubing mascara
Tubing mascaras have several unique benefits that may make them an appealing choice for those seeking a new mascara. These perks include:
- No smudging: Unlike traditional mascaras, which may smudge in the rain or upon contact with oil, tubing mascaras are completely smudge-proof—they hold up in all weather conditions, even if you have oily skin.
- Easy removal: Most tubing mascaras are water-resistant, but the tubes can be easily removed from the lashes with warm water and gentle rubbing. This makes them ideal for those seeking a mascara that won’t damage their lashes.
- Gentle on lashes: Less tugging during removal means reduced lash breakage—a major perk for those with sparse or fragile eyelashes.
- Provides length and definition: Tubing mascaras are ideal for those who want long, defined lashes. These formulas lift and lengthen while separating each lash for a fluttery look.
- Great for active lifestyles: Tubing mascaras won’t smudge, run, or flake in sweaty or humid conditions—so if you’re someone who likes to wear makeup to the gym, they’re a great option to consider.
How To Know if You Have a Tubing Mascara
If you hastily picked up a new mascara and are unsure whether it’s a standard or tubing formula, there are a few easy ways to figure out what you’re working with.
First, read your mascara’s label. If it lists polymers—the distinguishing ingredient of a tubing formula—on the packaging, it’s likely a tubing mascara. Another way to spot a tubing mascara is to pay attention to how it wears. Regular mascaras can sometimes transfer onto your skin after extended periods due to their inclusion of waxes and dyes (blotting your skin and applying setting powder can help prevent the dreaded panda eye). Tubing mascaras, on the other hand, are often resistant to the oils on your face and are less prone to smudging onto your lids or under-eye area.
Finally, pay attention to how your mascara is removed. If it slides right off your lashes in little strands, chances are good it is tubing mascara. These formulas remove easily with warm water (no makeup remover necessary).
Is Tubing Mascara Better for Your Lashes?
Tubing mascara isn’t better (or worse) for your lashes than regular mascara, though the easy removal may be ideal for those with a more sensitive eye area. Your personal preferences matter most when choosing between tubing mascara vs. regular mascara.
Tubing mascara is often a great choice for those with oily skin, as these formulas won’t melt, smudge, or smear the way some standard mascaras can. However, anyone craving dramatic lash volume might fare best with a traditional volumizing mascara. That’s because tubing mascaras generally aren’t as buildable as wax-based ones, making them ideal for a more natural, eyelash-lengthening look.
Similarly, consider when and where you plan to wear your mascara. Since tubing mascara melts off easily in water, it may not be the best choice if you plan to swim, sweat heavily, or stay in a place with rain. Waterproof mascaras, meanwhile, can typically hold up to wet conditions, but they can only be removed with eye makeup remover.
Ultimately, tubing and regular mascaras boast unique benefits. Each one can have a place in your makeup routine. Try experimenting with a few formulas and learn how to cocktail your mascara until you find your best fit.
L'Oréal Paris Tubing Mascara
Tubing mascaras don’t make up quite as much of the market as traditional ones, but you can still find them wherever you shop for makeup. If you’re looking for a reliable drugstore tubing mascara to add to your cart, try the L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes Tubing Mascara. This double-ended mascara features a nourishing ceramide-infused primer on one end and a pigmented tubing mascara on the other. Together, they leave the lashes looking 80% longer and provide all-day, smudge- and flake-proof wear. Plus, the mascara applies easily in just two simple steps. First, fully coat your lashes with the white base formula to prepare them for tubing. Then, sweep a layer of the tubing mascara onto your lashes for a lash extension-like effect that lasts until you wash it off.

How To Remove Tubing Mascara
Removing a tubing mascara might become the easiest part of your makeup routine. Simply splash water onto your face and gently pull the tubes away from your lashes using your fingertips. You’ll notice that they fall off in small clumps without much effort (rest assured, your lashes aren’t washing down the drain with them). Also, you can soak a cotton pad with warm water and hold it against your lashes for about 30 seconds. Once the liquid loosens the mascara, gently swipe it away with no mess or harsh tugging.
Next Up: How To Keep Your Lashes Curled: 8 Pro Tips
Photo courtesy of L’Oréal Paris