Double Extend Beauty Tubes™ Tubing Mascara

$14.99

Beauty Tubes is rated 4.1 out of 5 by 258.

Double-Extend-Beauty-Tubes - Black

Double-Extend-Beauty-Tubes-Blackest-Black - Blackest Black

Color

Blackest Black

MakeUp TryOn

Try Before you Buy

Product details

Discover Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara by L'Oréal Paris. Designed with ultra-nourishing base coat & lengthening top coat for longer-looking, nourished lashes.

Double Extend^® Beauty Tubes™ Mascara is a revolutionary lash extension effect mascara that provides up to 80% longer-looking, nourished lashes. -Step 1: Ultra-nourishing base coat infused with Ceramide R and D-Panthenol protects and strengthens lashes, creating the perfect base for tube application. -Step 2: Ultra-lengthening tube top coat sets to form lash-extending beauty tubes that visibly lengthen lashes to amazing new heights. Beauty tubes will not run, clump, flake or smudge and will stay on all-day. -Step 3: Beauty tubes remove easily with just warm water - no makeup remover or rubbing required. Ophthalmologist and allergy tested. Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Ingredients

STEP 1: AQUA / WATER / EAU • PARAFFIN • POTASSIUM CETYL PHOSPHATE • ACRYLATES • COPOLYMER • CERA ALBA / BEESWAX / CIRE DABEILLE • CERA CARNAUBA / CARNAUBA WAX / CIRE DE CARNAUBA • STEARETH-2 • CETYL ALCOHOL • PHENOXYETHANOL • HYDROXYETHYLCELLULOSE • ACACIA SENEGAL / ACACIA SENEGAL GUM • RAYON • PANTHENOL • ETHYLENEDIAMINE/STEARYL DIMER DILINOLEATE COPOLYMER • METHYLPARABEN • SODIUM DEHYDROACETATE • HYDROGENATED JOJOBA OIL • HYDROGENATED PALM OIL • 2-OLEAMIDO-1,3-OCTADECANEDIOL • DISODIUM EDTA • ETHYLPARABEN • SIMETHICONE • ROSA CANINA FRUIT OIL • ISOPROPYLPARABEN • ISOBUTYLPARABEN • BUTYLPARABEN STEP 2: AQUA / WATER / EAU • STYRENE/ACRYLATES/AMMONIUM METHACRYLATE COPOLYMER • BUTYLENE GLYCOL • ALCOHOL DENAT • ACRYLAMIDE/SODIUM • ACRYLOYLDIMETHYLTAURATE COPOLYMER • ISOHEXADECANE • PHENOXYETHANOL • SODIUM LAURETH-12 SULFATE • RAYON • POLYSORBATE 80 • METHYLPARABEN • IMIDAZOLIDINYL UREA • SODIUM DEHYDROACETATE • DISODIUM EDTA • ETHYLPARABEN • ISOPROPYLPARABEN • ISOBUTYLPARABEN • BUTYLPARABEN

Usage

Expert Application Technique. Place the basecoat brush at the base of lashes and gently sweep up to tip. Apply the Step 2 topcoat immediately after Step 1; no need to wait for drying time in between! Place the tube brush at the base of lashes and gently sweep up to tip.To remove: simply smooth tubes away with your fingertips when washing your face using plenty of warm water, or hold a cotton pad soaked in warm water on the lashes for 30 seconds.

skip tab component

Ratings and Reviews

Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Select a row below to filter reviews.

177 reviews with 5 stars.

23 reviews with 4 stars.

13 reviews with 3 stars.

8 reviews with 2 stars.

38 reviews with 1 star.

Overall Rating

4.1

Review this Product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.

Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

Most Helpful Favourable Review

5 out of 5 stars.

I can't live without this. PERIOD.

5 years ago

This is the ONLY mascara of its kind. When I cry, which is often because I'm sensitive, it doesn't run OR smear. However, since it's not waterproof when you want it off add water and it comes off in little tubules. It's incredible.

20 people found this helpful

Show Reviews:

Most Helpful Critical Review

1 out of 5 stars.

10 years ago

horrible,, what a waste of my money,, this is a nightmare to remove..

4 people found this helpful

Show Reviews:

Customer Images and Videos

Filter Reviews

satisfaction
effect on lashes
length
tube
removal
purchase
eyelashes
product availability

1 to 8 of 259 Reviews.

1 – 8 of 259 Reviews

Brown

Review 1

Votes 0

Age:25 to 34

Gender:Female

My eye color:Light Brown

My hair color:Medium Blonde

My complexion:Light

My undertone:Neutral Undertone

5 out of 5 stars.

Begging for brown!

2 days ago

PLEASE MAKE THIS IN BROWN!!!! Been using every day for probably 15 years now. It is simply the best. PLEASE MAKE IN BROWN

Would you purchase this again:Yes

Helpful?

Review 1

Votes 0

Age:35 to 44

Gender:Female

My eye color:Dark Brown

My hair color:Black

My complexion:Medium

1 out of 5 stars.

It doesn’t seem the same…

a month ago

For years this was literally the only mascara that would not smudge upon application or eventually leave me with dark circles. It also made my lashes look great! The last two tubes have not been up to the quality of the past. At first, I thought it was a fluke, but my most recent purchase has had the same poor performance. The smudges are particularly stubborn and hard to get off. My lashes also seem to stay a bit sticky or wet. I am bummed. I guess it’s back to the tubing mascara I used before this one. It is much more expensive and it doesn’t make my lashes look as nice, but I really cannot abide the smudges and the eventual dark circles. Let me know when the original is back.

Would you purchase this again:No

Helpful?

Response from L'Oreal:

a month ago

LeCare

Hello! Thank you for sharing your feedback on our Double Extend Beauty Tubes Tubing Mascara. We are so sorry to hear that your recent purchases have not performed the way you remember, especially after this product had been such a longtime favorite for you. We understand how disappointing and frustrating that must be. While we always strive to maintain the quality and performance you know and love, minor formula changes can occur over time. We have shared your comments regarding the smudging, texture, and wear with our team. In the meantime, you may wish to explore our washable mascara options here: https://tinyurl.com/26mdxzl3. We hope this helps you find a new favorite with L'Oréal Paris!

Review 1

Vote 1

Age:55 to 64

Gender:Female

My eye color:Blue

My complexion:Light

My undertone:Neutral Undertone

3 out of 5 stars.

Did the formula change? (sigh)

3 months ago

It seems that Loreal may have changed the formula for this product. It has been my tried and true, go-to mascara for years! It lengthened and defined my lashes, it didn't smudge or flake off - but it did wash off easily with soap and water. Perfection!! The last 3 tubes I've tried all have the same issue. It will not wash off. I don't want to risk pulling out my eyelashes trying to remove this stuff. What happened??

Would you purchase this again:No

Helpful?

Response from L'Oreal:

3 months ago

consumer care center

• Hi there, we are so sorry to hear the tubes are not just sliding off your lashes with soap and water as usual. There has been no change to the formula so we want to know what’s going on as much as you do! If you would like to speak with us directly, please give us a call @ 800-322-2036 Monday - Friday 9AM - 5:30PM EST for assistance and provide the reference # 45873403. Please have the product with you if available. We look forward to speaking with you.

Fairfax, VA

Review 1

Votes 0

Age:45 to 54

Gender:Female

My eye color:Green

My hair color:Medium Blonde

My complexion:Light

My undertone:Neutral Undertone

5 out of 5 stars.

Still my favorite after 17 years

4 months ago

I've been using Double Extend since 2009. It's literally the only mascara that doesn't smudge under my eyes. My only complaint is that eventually it will start to flake a little bit after the tube is a few months old. It's affordable enough though that I throw that one away and buy a new tube. I really don't know what I'll do if L'Oreal ever stops making this mascara

Would you purchase this again:Yes

Helpful?

Review 1

Votes 2

5 out of 5 stars.

THE BEST MASCARA

5 months ago

I've been using this mascara for years. It is highly underrated. Much cheaper than other tubing mascaras. I honestly think that L'Oreal should spend more $ promoting this product.

Helpful?

Review 1

Vote 1

5 out of 5 stars.

Love Beauty Tubes!

6 months ago

Best beauty product of my lifetime. No smudging and easy to remove.

Originally posted on Beauty Tubes Blackest Black

Helpful?

Review 1

Votes 2

5 out of 5 stars.

Amazing product

7 months ago

I love this mascara have been using it forever I never use the waterproof because I don’t like anything waterproof it’s horrible to take off. I have had experiences when bought it isn’t the same formula but I learned you can’t order and have it delivered especially from Amazon because not sure if it’s old or not. Walgreens definitely has old mascaras as well. As I said I love this mascara I have always got compliments and now with everyone wearing false lashes people think I wear lashes. I definitely recommend this mascara . Also for removal I love it it’s the easiest I just use warm water and brush with my fingers and it gently comes off. I have full lashes and they are not thin at all never lost any lashes either . One complaint I have is why don’t you make the brown anymore ? I like to use brown for every day use and the blackest black for going out because it is very dramatic. Thank you please don’t ever stop making this mascara it’s the best out there and so affordable!!!!!!

Helpful?

Montana

Review 1

Votes 0

Age:35 to 44

Gender:Female

1 out of 5 stars.

Felt like glue very sticky, took off my real eylas

7 months ago

I use to love this mascara back in 2019-2020. I bought it recently at Walgreens and it felt like glue was on my eyelashes and eye lid. When taking it off my eyelashes came off as well. So now I’m missing parts of my eyelashes. I don’t know what changed but please be careful. I would not recommend.

Would you purchase this again:No

Helpful?

Response from L'Oreal:

7 months ago

LeCare

Hi JMG7. ! We are sorry to hear about the experience you had with Beauty Tubes. We would like to speak with you directly about it. Please give us a call at 1-800-322-2036, M-F 9:00 am – 5:30 pm ET for assistance. It would be helpful if you could have the product available when you call. Looking forward to speaking with you.

1 – 8 of 259 Reviews

Next Reviews

Questions

1–10 of 31 Questions

Beauty Tubes
2 years ago

I purchased this and step 1white tube does not have a squeegee part to get the excess portion of the brush. Is this normal? If so, it's messy and goopy.

1 answer
1. Loreal Consumer Care USA
  
  2 years ago
  
  Hello enp. Thank you for sharing your comments on the Double Extend Beauty Tubes. We are sad to hear that you are having difficlty with the applicator. Feedback from our consumers is very important to us and helps us improve all of our products! We apologize that you did not end up liking this product and appreciate you sharing your experience! We hope you will continue to use our products with complete confidence and satisfaction!
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
3 years ago

Is this being discontinued? Several stores by me are out of stock.

1 answer
1. Loreal Consumer Care USA
  
  3 years ago
  
  Hello Amanda. Thanks for your interest in our Double-Extend-Beauty-Tubes. This is still a current product of ours, and can be purchased at most major drug and retailer stores. We recommend that you use the store locator on our website, here is the link to bring you there: https://tinyurl.com/2jkcz3v3 ! We thank you again for reaching out!
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
3 years ago

I often skip the primer and only use the topcoat. Do you sell topcoat separately? Or is there another product comparable?

1 answer
1. Loreal Consumer Care USA
  
  3 years ago
  
  Hello there, thank you for reaching out and asking us this question, we love to help our consumers in the best way possible. We will recommend 3 amazing products.
  1. L'Oréal Paris presents Voluminous® Lash Primer, the perfect pair to your favorite mascara to instantly boost every lash look. Lightweight eyelash primer instantly builds dramatic volume and length on each lash. Creates a boosting effect, building dramatic volume and length on each lash. Lash primer conditions over time for soft nourished lashes. Use mascara primer with your favorite L'Oréal Paris mascara to amplify every lash look.
  Pro tip - apply primer and then mascara to one eye at a time before the primer dries. Add two coats of primer for more impact.
  2. L'Oréal Paris presents Voluminous Lash Paradise™ Primer, a pink-tinted mascara primer that creates voluminous, thick eyelashes look while enhancing mascara wear. Conditioning lash primer formula, infused with rose oil, helps adhere mascara to lashes for enhanced mascara wear. A soft wavy mascara wand, with over 200 bristles, holds the maximum formula to coat and prepare lashes for mascara.
  And...
  3. L’Oréal Paris Lash Serum Solution conditions and nourishes your lashes with glycerin, pro-vitamin B5, hyaluronic acid, madecassoside, and arginine. 7 out of 10 women saw a reduction in lash loss during makeup removal. Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Ophthalmologist tested. Use alone or immediately before applying primer, mascara, eyeliner, or eyeshadow.
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
4 years ago

is this 100% vegan?

1 answer
1. Loreal Consumer Care USA
  
  4 years ago
  
  Hello Weva! We are happy to hear you are interested in Double-Extend-Beauty-Tubes. This product is not Vegan. We understand how frustrating this can be and we will certainly forward your concerns to our team. If you have any further questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact us. Thank you!
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
8 years ago

I have never done much with wearing makeup. Just curious on where to start and how to get started and easily determine shades and tones without having to go into a store. Also looking for something that will cover well and doesn’t look caked on.

1 answer
1. Consumer Care Center
  
  7 years ago
  
  Hi there! For the best color selections, we recommend you take a look at our Foundation Shade finder on our website, as well as our Virtual Try On feature. Both of these will help you find and visualize which shades will be best for you! If you would like further assistance on shade selection, call us at 800-322-2036 and we would be more than happy to assist you. We hope that you find your perfect match!
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
10 years ago

WATER PROFF?

1 answer
1. Consumer Care Center
  
  7 years ago
  
  Hi CHERYLANNSENESE! Thanks for reaching out to us regarding Double Extend Beauty Tubes. This product is available in both washable and waterproof formulas. We hope this helps.
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
7 years ago

Has this formula recently changed? My daughter an I have both been wearing this since it first came out and have both noticed a difference in consistency recently.

1 answer
1. Loreal Consumer Care USA
  
  7 years ago
  
  Hi, thank you for reaching out to L'Oreal. We're sorry to hear you found the consistency of the Double Extend Beauty Tubes to be different. We have not changed the formula. We appreciate your comments and will pass them on to others in our company.
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
7 years ago

Out of your entire mascara line, is this the one that lengthens lashes the most, or would you recommend one of your other mascaras for longer lashes?

1 answer
1. Loreal Consumer Care USA
  
  7 years ago
  
  Hi Makette- Thank you for your question regarding the best lengthening mascara on our line. The Double Extend Beauty Tube mascara has a ultra-nourishing base coat infused with Ceramide R and D-Panthenol protects and strengthens lashes, creating the perfect base for tube application. Step 2: Ultra-lengthening tube top coat sets to form lash-extending beauty tubes that visibly lengthen lashes to amazing new heights. This is a great choice! We can also suggest Unlimited Lash Lifting and Lengthening in either Waterproof or Washable Mascara. Click on the link to view http://tinyurl.com/yajo7gg5
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
7 years ago

Did L’Oréal stop making the black brown version of this mascara?

1 answer
1. Loreal Consumer Care USA
  
  7 years ago
  
  Hi Maria! We appreciate your interest in Double Extend Beauty Tubes. This product is only currently available in the shades Black and Blackest Black. We hope this was helpful.
  
  Helpful?
Beauty Tubes
7 years ago

Do you let the basecoat dry before adding the topcoat? Should you add the topcoat as soon as possible- ie one eye at a time, or do you let it set for ~30 seconds allowing both eyes to be primed then add the topcoat? Thanks,

1 answer
1. Loreal Consumer Care USA
  
  7 years ago
  
  Hi there! Place the basecoat brush at the base of lashes and gently sweep up to tip. Apply the Step 2 topcoat immediately after Step 1; no need to wait for drying time in between! Place the tube brush at the base of lashes and gently sweep up to tip. We hope this is helpful!
  
  Helpful?

1–10 of 31 Questions

Next Questions

tab component skipped

Rated 5 out of 5 by Ineedbrownmascara from Begging for brown! PLEASE MAKE THIS IN BROWN!!!! Been using every day for probably 15 years now. It is simply the best. PLEASE MAKE IN BROWN

Date published: 2026-07-18

Rated 1 out of 5 by VS23 from It doesn’t seem the same… For years this was literally the only mascara that would not smudge upon application or eventually leave me with dark circles. It also made my lashes look great! The last two tubes have not been up to the quality of the past. At first, I thought it was a fluke, but my most recent purchase has had the same poor performance. The smudges are particularly stubborn and hard to get off. My lashes also seem to stay a bit sticky or wet. I am bummed. I guess it’s back to the tubing mascara I used before this one. It is much more expensive and it doesn’t make my lashes look as nice, but I really cannot abide the smudges and the eventual dark circles. Let me know when the original is back.

Date published: 2026-05-31

Rated 3 out of 5 by hmm23 from Did the formula change? (sigh) It seems that Loreal may have changed the formula for this product. It has been my tried and true, go-to mascara for years! It lengthened and defined my lashes, it didn't smudge or flake off - but it did wash off easily with soap and water. Perfection!! The last 3 tubes I've tried all have the same issue. It will not wash off. I don't want to risk pulling out my eyelashes trying to remove this stuff. What happened??

Date published: 2026-03-27

Rated 5 out of 5 by Ehsmerelda from Still my favorite after 17 years I've been using Double Extend since 2009. It's literally the only mascara that doesn't smudge under my eyes. My only complaint is that eventually it will start to flake a little bit after the tube is a few months old. It's affordable enough though that I throw that one away and buy a new tube. I really don't know what I'll do if L'Oreal ever stops making this mascara

Date published: 2026-03-11

Rated 5 out of 5 by redbird64 from THE BEST MASCARA I've been using this mascara for years. It is highly underrated. Much cheaper than other tubing mascaras. I honestly think that L'Oreal should spend more $ promoting this product.

Date published: 2026-01-28

Rated 5 out of 5 by Kfitz from Love Beauty Tubes! Best beauty product of my lifetime. No smudging and easy to remove.

Date published: 2026-01-05

Rated 5 out of 5 by Tm2228 from Amazing product I love this mascara have been using it forever I never use the waterproof because I don’t like anything waterproof it’s horrible to take off. I have had experiences when bought it isn’t the same formula but I learned you can’t order and have it delivered especially from Amazon because not sure if it’s old or not. Walgreens definitely has old mascaras as well. As I said I love this mascara I have always got compliments and now with everyone wearing false lashes people think I wear lashes. I definitely recommend this mascara . Also for removal I love it it’s the easiest I just use warm water and brush with my fingers and it gently comes off. I have full lashes and they are not thin at all never lost any lashes either . One complaint I have is why don’t you make the brown anymore ? I like to use brown for every day use and the blackest black for going out because it is very dramatic. Thank you please don’t ever stop making this mascara it’s the best out there and so affordable!!!!!!

Date published: 2025-12-03

Rated 1 out of 5 by JMG7 from Felt like glue very sticky, took off my real eylas I use to love this mascara back in 2019-2020. I bought it recently at Walgreens and it felt like glue was on my eyelashes and eye lid. When taking it off my eyelashes came off as well. So now I’m missing parts of my eyelashes. I don’t know what changed but please be careful. I would not recommend.

Date published: 2025-11-20

Beauty Tubes Reviews - page 2

Rated 2 out of 5 by kneuba1 from Fair - the primer was non-existent Step 1 - the primer - was empty. I couldn't figure out what was supposed to happen until I saw an online review and it showed a white primer that you could actually see on your lashes. The quality control needs to be stepped up!

Date published: 2025-11-03

Rated 1 out of 5 by TexasT from Avoid at all costs! I couldn't find my usual mascara L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Superstar Washable Mascara, Blackest Black, so I thought I'd try this L'Oreal product (it looked similar) What a mistake! It is a nightmare to remove. No matter what method I try to use to remove it I would have a black residue on my face. Never again!

Date published: 2025-10-30

Rated 5 out of 5 by Linda Dee from 💯 highly recommend 🤩 I am 61 years old & an avid yaga & gym fitness. type. I'm holistic by nature & very light on makeup. I absolutely love this mascara, the best I've ever used. Been a wk & so far ❤️❤️❤️

Date published: 2025-10-27

Rated 5 out of 5 by Heat from The Holy Grail of Mascaras; But Please Add Brown Cons: 1 ) The Step 1 - Nourish & Protect is white: I think the way to improve upon this would be for L’Oreal to make the color just a few shades lighter than the intended result. 2 ) Stains: If it weren’t for the fact that this mascara has SO MANY other INCREDIBLE qualities, I would remove a star for this. If it happens to come off, which should be nearly non-existent, it will stain. I am yet to find anything that will remove it from fabric. 3) Only comes in two shades of black. Where is the variety? Pros: 1) Volume: This mascara is serious about providing thickness and length. 2 ) Tears-proof: Yes, within the past 2+ years I have cried in this mascara plenty and it hasn’t budged. 3 ) Oil-proof: I have oily skin, brows, and eyelids. All previous “waterproof” non-tubing mascaras will melt or flake below my lower lid by the end of the day. This one looks as good at the end of the day as it did at the beginning. 4 ) Blizzard-proof: This mascara has been tested multiple times in snowy, blizzard-like conditions and doesn’t budge one bit. 5 ) Sweat-proof: I’ve worked out and even had sweat stinging my eyes, more times than I can count, but this mascara will not run or smudge or flake. It remains flawless. 6 ) Humidity-proof: I have traveled to humid areas of the U.S. multiple times since having this mascara and it absolutely stayed put. 7 ) Waterproof: Mostly yes, but also no. I have been in pools, hot tubs, in the ocean, and of course my shower, and wash my face in the sink. I have been splashed in the eyes in all these places. Just getting the mascara wet, even with hot tub water, will not make it come off. It takes persistent wetness combined with rubbing to make it really come off. 8 ) Sleep-proof: Mostly. Firstly, I am not condoning sleeping in any mascara. You make that choice at your own risk. The results are likely to be a crapshoot unless you sleep with a giant dome-eyed face mask on. You may wake up with flawless lashes or your eyelashes may become clumped together or flake a little in your sleep. 9 ) Lasts for a long time: Yes, you already know from various things I’ve said that this mascara is figuratively bullet-proof. But one tube of it also seems to last a lot longer than I expected it to. L’Oreal Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara may have a name that’s excessively long (just like this review), and it may not sound very cool or sexy, but it will be the mascara you pray will never be discontinued and the mascara you’ve waited for your entire life. Now make it in Brown, L’Oreal!

Date published: 2025-09-13

Rated 5 out of 5 by Pia P from Love it I love how it extends my.eyelashes The best part it is smudge proof and does not require eye make up up remover just warm water and comes off easily. Love it. Please never discontinue this product

Date published: 2025-09-10

Rated 1 out of 5 by Mayra from I hate this mascara/lie of a mascara One of the worst mascara I have ever tried. I can’t believe I spent my money on this. It’s like black water on my eyes does not even stay. Doesn’t even look like I have a mascara on made me look like I barely have hair on my eyes. The opposite of what is meant to do. I dig through my trash just to get my old mascara because of how bad this mascara made me look

Date published: 2025-09-05

Rated 3 out of 5 by Judy from Always digging out lumps of mascara from inside tu I love this mascara, but I have to dig clumps out of the tube.

Date published: 2025-08-31

Rated 5 out of 5 by Lorry75 from The best mascara ever! It is the really Best eyelash mask ever! Please do not discontinue it.

Date published: 2025-06-09

Rated 1 out of 5 by Nan Goat from Not good! This mascara made my eyes very, very itchy! The brushes do not work very well at all. Was not happy with it. I have had cheap mascaras that are WAY better than this!

Date published: 2025-05-19

Rated 3 out of 5 by SarahS from Reformulation/Shelf-Life change? Has this product reformulated? I have bought faithfully via Amazon subscription for years and have the daily use and shelf life down to a science. Since fall of '24 i've had issues where it gets dry/clumpy by two months instead of the normal 3 months use life, so i need to buy more frequently. This is very disappointing.

Date published: 2025-05-13

Rated 5 out of 5 by Steph from Brown, please! Favorite mascara for several years - need in brown

Date published: 2025-04-30

Rated 4 out of 5 by Danielle from LOVE Love this mascara. I wish it came in brown instead only of black but regardless, this is the best lengthening mascara I’ve ever used. Zero issues with with tears or sweat and removal is so easy!

Date published: 2025-03-24

Rated 5 out of 5 by Mindyu from Best mascara ever Best mascara I’ve ever used!!! I try others and always end up back with this one. I love how it doesn’t flake out smudge which I have such a problem with. Then to take it off just some warm water and the tubes come right off. No mess around my eyes. It’s just the best!!!

Date published: 2025-03-24

Rated 5 out of 5 by Anna from Please make this in Brown!!! The BEST mascara I’ve found that doesn’t leave residue around your eyes as you wear it all day. I REALLY REALLY wish it came in brown. This is the best.

Date published: 2025-02-09

Rated 5 out of 5 by Wibz from Great mascara I love this mascara so much but wish it came in brown! Please make a brown version!

Date published: 2025-02-01

Rated 5 out of 5 by sylwiawek from best ever I have been using this mascara for years, its absolutely the best quality and super easy to take off no smudges at all no black eyes.

Date published: 2025-01-27

Rated 5 out of 5 by Krissi from Holy Grail Mascara This has been my go-to mascara for over a decade. It doesn’t clump, flake, or smudge and doesn’t irritate my extremely sensitive eyes. It comes off easily with warm water.

Date published: 2024-12-15

Rated 5 out of 5 by mk27 from Best My Eyelashes Have Looked I don't in general like multi-step products but this was worth it because my eyelashes were long and voluminous.

Date published: 2024-10-21

Rated 5 out of 5 by marthasf from LOVE - no flaking and lashes stay curled all day! So far I am very impressed with this mascara. Why didn't I know about tubing mascara years ago?! I prefer to only use the black mascara end as the white pre-conditioning left my lashes a bit too clumpy and takes more time to apply and then separate. What I love is that there is no flaking AND my lashes once curled STAY CURLED ALL DAY. Only waterproof mascara has ever done this. I also love how easy it is to remove with warm water. Please don't discontinue this product and may add a version with only the black color!

Date published: 2024-09-12

Rated 4 out of 5 by EG98 from Great product, not easy to remove I really like how this mascara doesn’t rub or smudge. It’s a little more difficult to remove than the product description says. I will buy again.

Date published: 2024-08-02

Rated 5 out of 5 by Dems from Double extended mascara Size I LOVEEEE THISS TUBING mascara but I wish that I came in a larger size with out the primer! Pleaseee lorealll give me one that’s bigger ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Date published: 2024-07-19

Rated 4 out of 5 by Nana j from Did not clump after using the condtioner end Love the product. However I really liked the double extend with the black conditioner and black mascara. Cannot find it anywhere.

Date published: 2024-07-12

Rated 5 out of 5 by Helena from Why? I've been using this for 25 years since I was 18 years old. It's so hard for me to buy this recently that I can't keep wondering why this freaking good product is not popular these days.

Date published: 2024-06-30

Rated 5 out of 5 by LeeS from Decade I been using it for over a decade love it it is smudge proof and long lasting looks good even next day of u forgot to wash your face .

Date published: 2024-06-16

Rated 5 out of 5 by Dee0204 from Love it! Absolutely love this it’s so easy to take off and it keep my eyelashes up all day! And it doesn’t run!

Date published: 2024-06-07

Rated 5 out of 5 by Hullie from Nothing Else Compares This is the best tubing mascara there is. I know because I've tried them all. Movie makeup people love it. I've used it from the time it was introduced. There really is nothing like it.

Date published: 2024-06-06

Rated 5 out of 5 by DENumber1Fan from Best Mascara I've Ever Used Have been using this for years! I love that the wand is not curved so I can control it better. I just bought a different L'oreal mascara because I couldn't find this, and have spent two days looking like a raccoon. This product is truly smudge-proof and yet comes off easily with water when I WANT it to!

Date published: 2024-05-25

Rated 5 out of 5 by FragFree from No Irritated eyes. No smudges. Even waterproof mascara smudged around my eyes. My Eyes were always red when I wore mascara. I started using Beauty Tubes mascara and no smudging and my eyes are never red. Beaty Tubes all the way! Tip: Don’t forget the base coat dry before you add the black on top!

Date published: 2024-04-10

Rated 3 out of 5 by 916a from Meh... Only trying it because I have oily eyelids and everything else smudges. Not a fan of having to use two steps and it certainly doesn't make my lashes 80% longer as advertised.

Date published: 2024-04-07

Rated 5 out of 5 by Paola915 from Excellent mascara Very good mascara, I love it! Hopefully they don't discontinue this product because, I finally found a mascara that goes well with my eyelashes. The mascara does not weight down my eyelashes and the volume that it gives my eyelashes is amazing.

Date published: 2024-03-25

Beauty Tubes Reviews - page 3

Rated 5 out of 5 by Linn from Best beauty tube mascara I have sparse, short, straight lashes. I also have dry sensitive eyes. This mascara give me to die for lashes. I get asked what mascara I use all the time. I love that it just washes off with warm water....no rubbing or tugging or lash loss or panda eyes trying to wash this mascara off like others products. It's great for a full makeup look as well as a no makeup look. Most days I just do brows, mascara and lipgloss... The no hassle clean up is the best. I also love that it is dual ended with both the primer and mascara. One less product to buy/taking up room in my makeup bag. I'm surprised this product doesn't get more love. I have been using it for years, now it's what my daughter uses as well.

Date published: 2024-03-17

Rated 5 out of 5 by Awadaa from BEST MASCARA EVER This is the best mascara ever hands down. Compared to any and every mascara out there. Full volume, long lengths, last all day. Please don't discontinue this mascara. I've used it for at least a decade. Truly will be heartbroken. Please don't discontinue.

Date published: 2024-02-28

Rated 1 out of 5 by Denverbabe99 from Cruelty Free Come on Loreal! Cruelty Free products! I will not use your double extend mascara until you shape up!!! It's the 21st century, get on it!

Date published: 2024-02-06

Rated 5 out of 5 by Kelz from Loreal Double Extension - DISCONTINUED This is the best mascara EVER, why have you discontinued it.... I cant find it anywhere in store or online... :( DEVASTATED

Date published: 2024-01-26

Rated 5 out of 5 by CherryTree from Perfect mascara! I’ve been using this product for 13+ years. It is the ONLY mascara I’ve found that doesn’t give me panda eyes and it makes my short, straight lashes length. Love this and recommend it every chance I get.

Date published: 2024-01-13

Rated 5 out of 5 by Bianca from The best I tried so far It's really volumizing and lengthening. I would love more if the white coating was not white, but brown or gray. I would also love to have a dark brown color option for the mascara. People that say that this mascara break their lashes are not very smart. It gives fake extension with the coating + mascara. So when you remove it, it is not your lashes falling, it's the product, duh.

Date published: 2024-01-03

Rated 1 out of 5 by Mini from Plastic/rubbery texture New formula is ripping my lashes out washing out daily.

Date published: 2023-11-19

Rated 5 out of 5 by Christascott06 from #1 Mascara on the market! I’ve been using this product for years! I always have people ask me if I’ve gotten lash extensions, it’s that good! I love telling friends that it’s literally the best mascara on the market without breaking the bank!!!!

Date published: 2023-10-22

Rated 5 out of 5 by A Jay from Best for stubborn lashes The only mascara I use … primer helps separate stubborn lashes … and the mascara gives a little extra length

Date published: 2023-09-27

Rated 5 out of 5 by Jaimee from The BEST Mascara! I have been wearing this mascara for over 10 years! I noticed it is hard to find now. Please don’t discontinue it! It’s the only mascara I have found that doesn’t smudge but is easy to take off when you want to remove it. I seriously want to cry and with this mascara on it wouldn’t smudge :(

Date published: 2023-09-18

Rated 5 out of 5 by LizA from Best Mascara on the Market This is the BEST mascara eve!! I’ve been using it for many, many years. It gives great volume and length. AND it doesn’t run - no raccoon eyes!!!

Date published: 2023-09-17

Rated 5 out of 5 by EG123 from Love. I have used this mascara for many years and I won’t use any other. I love the way I can use warm water and a mild cleanser and all of mascara easily comes off. The formula extends my lashes wonderfully too; they are full and long looking. I get lots of compliments.

Date published: 2023-09-17

Rated 5 out of 5 by Great mascara from Best Mascara! Please don’t leave! The absolute BEST mascara out there! I am getting worried as it’s been harder and harder to find. Can you please make sure this never leaves the shelves? Thank you!

Date published: 2023-09-06

Rated 5 out of 5 by Nikola from Best Mascara Best mascara out there. Have tried many different brands and types but none beat this particular product

Date published: 2023-07-31

Rated 5 out of 5 by Laura22 from The ONLY mascara that doesn’t flake/smudge! Love! I’ve tried COUNTLESS mascaras and they all flanks/smudge under my eyes. This is the only one I have found that does not! It washes away completely smudge free as well! Pleeeease never discontinue this item! It’s my favorite product in my entire makeup bag!

Date published: 2023-07-21

Rated 5 out of 5 by Joyrose from Excellent Product I've used this for years, and find it works just as it's promised., with long lashes, no clumping, and easy to remove. I use Cetaphil and water to dampen, and let sit for a few minutes and rinse it off, with no lash breakage, when washing my face at the end of the day.

Date published: 2023-07-13

Rated 5 out of 5 by MaryRN from Please don’t ever discontinue it!! I love this mascara! I have been using it for around 15 years now. Today I went to stock up at Ulta and I did not see it on the display. I asked the sales associate about it. She looked it up and it said that it was out of stock online and she did not have any in store. She thought that maybe it was being discontinued. I am shattered. I hope that it isn’t discontinued and just that Ulta stopped carrying it. Please do not ever stop making this. Everything else would cause smudging around my brow, bone and beneath my eye area. I’ve tried so many mascaras, and this is the only one that doesn’t leave smudges. I have oily skin and I use a lot of creams. Please don’t ever discontinue it, room those with oily skin need this mascara!

Date published: 2023-06-25

Rated 5 out of 5 by Holmeslice333 from BEST MASCARA AROUND. I LOVE this mascara. I love the way it creates a covering for each eyelash. Please never, ever stop making this mascara. I have gotten so many people to start using this. My local Target has not had it for weeks and I had to find it on Amazon after trying 3 other types of L’Oréal mascara. My only criticism: I will say that I do NOT use the white primer. It never hides well enough, no matter how many coats of the black I do. I wish you could make the primer black as well. PLEASE. For awhile you offered another double ended mascara that did have a blackish gray primer but it was not the beauty tubes and I threw it away.

Date published: 2023-06-22

Rated 5 out of 5 by AlamoRose from Best mascara EVER! It is the ONLY mascara I have found that truly comes off without smudging and with simply soap and water. As a contact lens wearer it is the only mascara that doesn’t bother my eyes by the end of the day.

Date published: 2023-06-22

Rated 5 out of 5 by itshotinFL from HOLY GRAIL PRODUCT Please, for the LOVE of Loreal, don't ever discontinue this product. The oily gals with long lashes cannot wear anything else. My lashes are so long they hit my eye bone and traditional mascara rubs off easily when I get oily. I've tried other tubing mascaras too and nothing compares to this.

Date published: 2023-06-16

Rated 5 out of 5 by Megan8 from Best Mascara Love it! It is a game changer for me! I have short, light color eyelashes. It makes them look 80% longer.! Easy to remove. I hold s warm washcloth over eyes & it wiped right off. Does not smudge under eyes during the day. Love this product!!!

Date published: 2023-06-10

Rated 5 out of 5 by Dibrook from Love love love the "tubes"! This is my absolute favorite mascara. I don't even use the white side. But I love the "tubes" and how it washes off. This is the only mascara like this around anymore!

Date published: 2023-05-21

Rated 5 out of 5 by Roxanne from Bruh No problems with irritation so far, kind of dislike the double formula as yes I am just that lazy. Easy to remove iykyk about tubing mascara. Bought as a replacement for my favorite boots tubing mascara that I can’t find anywhere anymore.

Date published: 2023-05-05

Rated 1 out of 5 by bc228 from Terrible Product Do not buy this! I’ve never had this experience but I’ve used this mascara twice and both times felt like my eyes were burning! I use other L’Oreal mascaras and they are fine. But this one specifically make your eyes feel like they are burning.

Date published: 2023-04-20

Rated 5 out of 5 by SR17 from Best My favorite for over a decade. Please make it in brown! Doesn’t smudge or come off with watery eyes, but easily comes off with just water. 10/10

Date published: 2023-04-01

Rated 5 out of 5 by Sirius thecat from Life without mascara stains around your eyes. I've been using this since it came out. I even wear it to the beach. If it gets too wet you just rinse them off. No looking like Alice Cooper when you take it off. My own lashes are healthier than ever as they stay protected.

Date published: 2023-03-27

Rated 5 out of 5 by LashSnob from Perfect and easy to remove! This is hands down the best mascara. For those saying it’s difficult to remove, it is not. It’s the EASIEST to remove. Here’s how: get your washcloth sloppy wet with warm water, bend over the sink with the washcloth against your eyes for about 10 seconds…and it ALL comes od easy peasy. Second method: get in the shower and it all just floats off. What will make it stick is, ironically, eye remover/soap. For a mascara th that comes off so easily with warm water, Thai actually stays ON through tears, North Carolina humidity, work, and a day at the pool. It never smudges or flakes. I’ve used it for 5 years and people tell me I have beautiful lashes. L’ORÉAL: please make this in BROWN!!

Date published: 2023-03-19

Rated 1 out of 5 by Soos from Looks like plastic I can hardly see it on! it looks like plastic and crumbles off in chunks. Does not add any volume.

Date published: 2023-02-26

Rated 5 out of 5 by sewfashion from Best In the 60 years I've been using mascara!! I've used this since it was introduced, 10-15 years ago, easily, or more! If you're over 50 this is a brilliant mascara, since not only does it not smudge, clump, or run, it removes without any rubbing whatsoever. Your delicate under eye skin is particularly vulnerable to wrinkling and this easy removal requires no rubbing or application of oily remover. Simply wet a washcloth (I love the Olay cleansing cloths that you use with water), and then close an eye and hold the cloth on your lashes.. Wait a few seconds and it wipes right off cleanly onto the cloth AND you'll ever wake up in the morning without smudgy black under your eyes. I've passed this information along to my fashion newsletter followers for as long as I've used it, and hundreds swear by it, with the average age growing from mid forties to now late fifties to eighty. It does lengthen your lashes beautifully and is superior for an enhanced lash that looks great for minimum to maximum makeup aficionados. I've been so afraid it might be discontinued since cosmetic companies frequently replace products, that I'm never without at least 4 or 5 in my makeup stash, just in case. Superior product, superior wear, superior look!s

Date published: 2023-01-13

Rated 5 out of 5 by Lolo Lynn from HUGE Fan Critic Best Mascara Ever!! Nothing on the market like it. No more running,flaking or needing remover to get rid of the raccoon eyes. I've been using this mascara consistently for almost 10yrs. My biggest fear is it getting discontinued. I ALWAYS get compliments on my lashes. My only issue, and this is just something I've noticed in the last year or two. They seem to be half empty and dried out. Going on all clumpy and crumbly. Or they're good but only last a couple weeks before it starts clumping. It NEVER did that before. I buy them two at a time now because of this. And it doesn't matter where I buy them either. It's SUPER depressing!!

Date published: 2022-12-26

Beauty Tubes Reviews - page 4

Discover more tips & tricks

See all articles

Skip the slider: Default related articles

Discover more tips & tricks

See all articles

Related ProductsDiscover More

RevitaLift

Triple Power Eye Bag Instant Eraser for Under-Eye Bags, Wrinkles & Puffiness

$ 24.99

4/5

Excellence

Crème Triple Care Permanent Hair Color for 100% Gray Hair Coverage

$ 12.99

3.8/5

Age Perfect Makeup

Radiant Serum Foundation with SPF 50

$ 18.99

4.5/5

Lumi

True Match Lumi Glotion Natural Glow Enhancer & Tinted Moisturizer

$ 17.99

4.5/5

Colour Riche

Colour Riche Satin Lipstick for Luxurious Hydration and Color

$ 10.99

4.2/5

Le Color Gloss

One Step In-Shower Toning Gloss

$ 15.99

4.6/5

Infallible

Up to 24H Fresh Wear Foundation in a Powder

$ 18.99

4.1/5

Infallible

Infallible 32 Hour Fresh Wear Foundation

$ 18.99

4.4/5

Double Extend Beauty Tubes™ Tubing Mascara

MakeUp TryOn

Ratings and Reviews

Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Overall Rating

Review this Product

Most Helpful Favourable Review

I can't live without this. PERIOD.

Most Helpful Critical Review

Customer Images and Videos

Filter Reviews

Begging for brown!

It doesn’t seem the same…

Did the formula change? (sigh)

Still my favorite after 17 years

THE BEST MASCARA

Love Beauty Tubes!

Amazing product

Felt like glue very sticky, took off my real eylas

Questions

I purchased this and step 1white tube does not have a squeegee part to get the excess portion of the brush. Is this normal? If so, it's messy and goopy.

Is this being discontinued? Several stores by me are out of stock.

I often skip the primer and only use the topcoat. Do you sell topcoat separately? Or is there another product comparable?

is this 100% vegan?

I have never done much with wearing makeup. Just curious on where to start and how to get started and easily determine shades and tones without having to go into a store. Also looking for something that will cover well and doesn’t look caked on.

WATER PROFF?

Has this formula recently changed? My daughter an I have both been wearing this since it first came out and have both noticed a difference in consistency recently.

Out of your entire mascara line, is this the one that lengthens lashes the most, or would you recommend one of your other mascaras for longer lashes?

Did L’Oréal stop making the black brown version of this mascara?

Do you let the basecoat dry before adding the topcoat? Should you add the topcoat as soon as possible- ie one eye at a time, or do you let it set for ~30 seconds allowing both eyes to be primed then add the topcoat? Thanks,

Discover more tips & tricks

Infallible Foundation: How To Find Your Perfect Shade and Texture

The Glycolic Acid Serum Your Skin Care Routine Needs

Should You Wash Your Hair Before Dyeing It?

How To Go From Black to Brown Hair at Home

Purple Shampoo and Brown Hair: The Secret to Cooler, Richer Tones

Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Overall Rating

Review this Product

Most Helpful Favourable Review

I can't live without this. PERIOD.

Most Helpful Critical Review

Customer Images and Videos

Filter Reviews

Begging for brown!

It doesn’t seem the same…

Did the formula change? (sigh)

Still my favorite after 17 years

THE BEST MASCARA

Love Beauty Tubes!

Amazing product

Felt like glue very sticky, took off my real eylas

Questions

Jenp

I purchased this and step 1white tube does not have a squeegee part to get the excess portion of the brush. Is this normal? If so, it's messy and goopy.

Amanda

Is this being discontinued? Several stores by me are out of stock.

Topcoat

I often skip the primer and only use the topcoat. Do you sell topcoat separately? Or is there another product comparable?

weva

is this 100% vegan?

Jkramer

I have never done much with wearing makeup. Just curious on where to start and how to get started and easily determine shades and tones without having to go into a store. Also looking for something that will cover well and doesn’t look caked on.

CHERYLANNSENESE

WATER PROFF?

The Go Go girls

Has this formula recently changed? My daughter an I have both been wearing this since it first came out and have both noticed a difference in consistency recently.

Makette

Out of your entire mascara line, is this the one that lengthens lashes the most, or would you recommend one of your other mascaras for longer lashes?

Maria43

Did L’Oréal stop making the black brown version of this mascara?

SSE99

Do you let the basecoat dry before adding the topcoat? Should you add the topcoat as soon as possible- ie one eye at a time, or do you let it set for ~30 seconds allowing both eyes to be primed then add the topcoat? Thanks,