Your Shopping Bag (4 items)

You are $75 away from free shipping




Order Subtotal $
pin cart mail search

5 Makeup Mistakes That Could Happen When You Fill in Your Eyebrows

Eye Makeup

5 Makeup Mistakes That Could Happen When You Fill in Your Eyebrows 5 Makeup Mistakes That Could Happen When You Fill in Your Eyebrows 5 Makeup Mistakes That Could Happen When You Fill in Your Eyebrows

You’ve mastered putting on mascara and even how to contour for your face shape, but what about filling in your eyebrows? Figuring out eyebrow makeup isn’t always the easiest thing to do. That’s why makeup mistakes concerning the eyebrows are all too common. Of course, it’s pretty hard to determine whether you’re getting it right or not unless you know which mistakes to be on the lookout for. Keep reading to find out five makeup mistakes you may be making when you fill in your eyebrows.


When it comes time to pick out an eyebrow product, you may believe it’s best to select one in a shade that exactly matches your eyebrow hairs. We understand how that would seemingly make sense, after all, you’re supposed to choose foundation that perfectly matches your skin tone. However, eyebrow makeup is a little different. The color you use to fill in your eyebrows should actually be a shade lighter than your hair. The lighter hue will be ideal for filling in any gaps without looking unnatural. The only exception here is for blondes with extremely light brow hairs. In this case, you’ll obviously want to add more color to your brows, so choose a brow product that’s specifically formulated for blondes, like the L'Oréal Paris Unbelieva-Brow Longwear Waterproof Brow Gel in Blonde.


While it’s true that bold eyebrows are trending, that doesn’t negate the fact that it’s still possible to go overboard with eyebrow makeup. Filling in your brows with a product that’s way too dark, making your eyebrows one solid shade, and creating eyebrows that are too big for your facial features can all lead to an overly dramatic look. Even if you want to copy your favorite celebrity or social media influencer’s bold eyebrows, the goal should be natural-looking eyebrows. In addition to using a product that’s the right shade, be sure to fill in your eyebrows so that they are less defined at the front—this mimics how eyebrows naturally grow and helps keep your eyebrows from looking totally over the top.


No doubt you learned when you were young that it’s good to color inside the lines—but that rule isn’t always true for filling in your eyebrows. Yes, you can fill in only the area where you already have eyebrow hairs, but that isn’t your sole option—you can go a little outside of the natural shape of your eyebrows. You may be missing out on your best eyebrows by being scared to color outside the lines, so give it a shot. Try using eyebrow makeup to change the shape of your eyebrows. If you aren’t a fan, you can always clean up with a cotton swab dipped in micellar water.


One minute the hottest eyebrow shape is an extreme arch and the next it’s a super-straight eyebrow. And chances are, not every popular shape will suit you. Just as it’s unavoidable that there will be certain hair colors that don’t work with your coloring, some eyebrow shapes won’t complement your face shape and features. Even if an unflattering shape is unbelievably popular, you’ll be better off finding a shape that works for your face. Here are general guidelines to follow:

If you have a round face…try a high arch.

If you have a square face…try a soft, low arch.

If you have an oval face…try a soft angled eyebrow.

If you have a long face…try a straight eyebrow.

If you have a diamond face…try a curved eyebrow.

If you have a heart-shaped face…try a rounded eyebrow.


There’s no reason to limit to yourself to filling in your eyebrows with just one product. You’re likely to get better results by mixing and matching different products. Keep an eyebrow pencil, eyebrow pomade, eyebrow mascara, and eyebrow highlighter on hand to shape, define, and fill in your eyebrows. Try the L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Shape & Fill Mechanical Pencil, L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Frame and Set, L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Boost & Set Brow Mascara, and the L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Brow Raiser Highlighter Duo.

Your eyebrows aren’t the only part of your look that you may be getting wrong! Check out the 8 Blush Mistakes You Could Be Making.