How to Apply Waterline Eyeliner Like a Pro

Waterline eyeliner is a game-changer in the beauty world, instantly sharpening and defining your eyes. Whether you're aiming for a subtle lash enhancement or a bold, smoky effect, mastering this technique can elevate your eye makeup game. Let’s dive into how to apply eyeliner to the waterline like a pro, from choosing the best products to ensuring a smudge-free finish.

Is It Safe to Put Eyeliner on Your Waterline?

Absolutely, you can apply eyeliner to your waterline, but it’s important to do so carefully. Because the waterline eye area is sensitive, using the wrong formula can lead to irritation or discomfort. The key is to choose eyeliners that are made specifically for this part of the eye.

Choose the right waterline eyeliner

Before applying eyeliner, make sure your product is ophthalmologist-tested, waterproof, and free of shimmer or glitter. These types of formulas are designed to stay in place without migrating into the eye or causing redness. Waterproof pencils with a smooth texture are usually the safest and most comfortable choice.

One to try is the L'Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Up To 24HR Pencil Eyeliner, available in different shades like Black, Burgundy, and Forest Green for endless possibilities. This eyeliner can last up to 24 hours with zero smudging and no irritation.

Refresh your eye products often

To keep your eyes safe, remember to replace your eyeliner regularly. Pencil liners should be swapped out every 12 months, while gel or liquid formulas every 3 to 6 months. This helps avoid product buildup and prevents unwanted bacteria from getting too close to your eyes.

Which Eyeliner Is Best for the Waterline?

The waterline eye area can be a challenging area to line, but the right eyeliner can make all the difference. Because this part is more sensitive and exposed to moisture, not every formula will stay put or feel comfortable. If you’re looking for the best eyeliner for the waterline, here’s what to look for.

Choose creamy formulas

When applying eyeliner to your waterline, creamy liners are your best bet. Unlike waxy or dry formulas that can feel harsh and tug on this delicate area, creamy textures glide on effortlessly and offer better comfort. Try the L'Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner for a rich, creamy, fade-proof formula.

Look for gel pencils or mechanical liners

Gel pencils and mechanical liners, like the L'Oréal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner, are ideal for the waterline eye area because they offer both precision and staying power. Their smooth consistency makes them easy to apply without irritation. These types of liners are especially helpful for quick, clean touch-ups.

Go for smudge-proof, water-resistant wear

To keep your tightline eyeliner looking sharp all day, opt for smudge-proof and water-resistant formulas. These features are key to preventing your liner from fading, transferring, or running, especially if you have watery or sensitive eyes. Try the L'Oréal Paris Infallible Grip Precision Felt Waterproof Eyeliner for the grip you need for up to 30 hours.

How to Tightline Your Upper Waterline

Tightlining is a subtle yet powerful way to make your lashes appear fuller. It adds definition right at the roots and brightens your eyes. Here’s how to nail the technique:

1. Expose your upper waterline

Applying eyeliner on the waterline can be tricky, so you want to reveal the lash base to achieve a better look. Gently lift your upper lid with a clean finger or cotton swab to expose the waterline. This will also help prevent the liner from pulling on the skin and make waterline eyeliner application a lot easier.

2. Absorb excess moisture

Before applying waterline eyeliner, use a tissue or cotton swab to blot the area. A dry surface ensures better product adhesion and reduces the chances of smudging. This step is crucial for long-lasting wear on the sensitive waterline eye area.

3. Gently apply the eyeliner

Using a waterproof liner, glide the tip along the upper waterline in short, precise strokes. Avoid pressing too hard to maintain a clean line. This technique enhances lash fullness without` obvious makeup lines.

4. Bonus pro tip

Take it one step further by softly lining your upper lash line using the same eyeliner shade. For a bolder look, try adding a buildable mascara to your lashes, such as the L’Oréal Paris Big Deal Buildable Waterproof Mascara. It’s lightweight and doesn’t clump no matter how much you layer.

How to Apply Eyeliner to Your Lower Waterline

Under-eye eyeliner can add drama or softness, depending on your choice of shade and style. Here’s how to apply eyeliner with finesse:

Expose your waterline

Tilt your chin up and gently pull down your lower lid to access the waterline. Keeping your eye relaxed helps prevent tearing. This position will allow you to apply eyeliner as close to the lashes as possible.

Absorb excess moisture

As with your upper line, blot the area to ensure your liner adheres properly. A dry base is key for smudge prevention. This step helps maintain a clean, defined look throughout the day.

Line the waterline

Take your waterproof liner and glide it gently along the lower waterline. Aim to stay close to the lashes for the cleanest effect. If you’re having trouble with precision, you can go by bits with short strokes.

Set the eyeliner with eyeshadow

Lock in your liner by pressing a matching shadow powder over it. The powder absorbs moisture and oil, extending wear time. It also softens the look for a blended, professional finish.

Makeup Tips to Keep Eyeliner From Smearing or Fading

To ensure your waterline eyeliner stays put, a few simple tricks can make a big difference. From prepping your skin to choosing the right formula, these expert-approved tips will help your eyeliner stay crisp, clean, and exactly where you want it all day long.

Use a primer for long wear

Before applying eyeliner, prep your lash line with a small amount of eye primer. It creates a smooth, oil-free surface that helps your liner grip better and last longer. Just make sure to let it fully dry before applying your waterline eyeliner for maximum staying power.

Sharpen your pencil before each use

A freshly sharpened tip helps you create precise lines and keeps things more hygienic. Dull pencils can tug on the waterline eye area and lead to uneven color payoff or irritation. Clean tools also help your eyeliner on the waterline stay smooth and in place throughout the day.

Avoid touching your eyes

It sounds simple, but it really helps. Try not to rub or touch your eyes during the day. Whether it's adjusting contacts or dealing with allergies, extra pressure can break down your waterline eyeliner and cause it to smear. If you’re careful, your tightline eyeliner will stay intact much longer.

Apply in layers

Instead of doing one heavy swipe, try building up the color in two or three thin layers. This method gives the formula time to set between passes and makes it more resistant to smudging. It’s especially helpful if your eyes tend to water when applying eyeliner to the waterline.

What Color Eyeliner Works Best for Your Eye Color?

The right waterline eyeliner color can do more than define your eyes; it can make them stand out in the best way. Whether you're going for something bold or just want to subtly enhance your natural tone, here’s how to pick the perfect shade to make your eyes pop.

Blue eyes

Copper, bronze, and navy tones create a striking contrast that enhances blue eyes. These shades add warmth and intensity, making your eyes pop. Whether tightlining or going full glam, these hues always deliver impact.

Brown eyes

Rich shades like plum, emerald, and deep blue bring out golden flecks in brown eyes. These colors create a multidimensional effect, enhancing depth and vibrancy. Try layering these tones on your waterline eyeliner for a bold twist.

Green eyes

Burgundy and violet tones complement green eyes beautifully. These shades enhance the natural cool and golden tones in the iris. A swipe of burgundy on the under-eye eyeliner can instantly intensify your gaze.

Hazel eyes

Earthy tones like gold and olive highlight the chameleon-like quality of hazel eyes. These shades allow for flexibility with your makeup look. They enhance the shifting hues, making your eyes stand out.

Finish the look with eyeshadow that pops

Take things up a notch with a complementary eyeshadow shade. A swipe of shimmer or a wash of color on the lid can enhance the tones in your eyes even more. Try the L’Oréal Paris Paradise Le Shadow Stick, available in shades like Twilight Emerald, Starry Bordeaux, Magnetic Bronze, and Alluring Rose.

How to Remove Eyeliner From Your Waterline

Gentle removal is crucial for maintaining eye health. Soak a cotton pad with micellar water or a gentle oil-based remover and press it on your closed eye to loosen the liner. Avoid rubbing or tugging, especially near the lash line. Use a cotton swab to clean any remaining product, then rinse with cool water or follow with a gentle cleanser for refreshed, happy eyes.

Next Up: How To Wear Brown Liquid Eyeliner, Plus 11 Looks To Try

Photo courtesy of L’Oréal Paris

Photo credit: IG/@facesbylindsay / @tiffanyleighpatton