This liner is perfection. It provides intense color and goes on smoothly. It's easy to work with and lasts all day. Thankfully, that doesn't mean it's hard to wash off because it NOT. The sharpener included is a nice and useful addition. If you want quality, I'd highly recommend using the L'Oreal Voluminous Smoldering Liner. I've tur...ned three friends on to it and now they're addicted!

i absolutely love this product, i have been waiting for years for a chubby liner stick. i use it in place of liquid liner and shadow liners. please dont ever stop making it!!!

I was never a khol liner girl but i kept seeing this liner all over YT so I tried it. its not good as a lid liner because it totally transfers onto the lid. So i tried it on the waterlines and OMG this stuff doesnt budge at all when used on the waterlines!! I love it so much I bought a back up in black and a brown one!

Love the way this pencil glides on and stays put for hours!

Nothing out of the ordinary. Wish it would stay on longer. Big pencil though, so I'm sure I'll have this for a while. Looks really good when gently smudged on the upper lid with a q-tip.